AHTC made it clear it wanted other firms to stay away: Davinder

The Aljunied-Hougang Town Council (AHTC), in waiving a tender for a new managing agent in 2011, and appointing a firm associated with the Workers' Party (WP), sent a "loud and clear" message to the township management industry, said Senior Counsel Davinder Singh.

That message was "don't bother" bidding for its contract as the WP-run town council would be doing things its own way, he charged when cross-examining WP chief Pritam Singh yesterday.

Hence, no one - except for one firm - bid for the managing agency and Essential Maintenance Service Unit contracts which AHTC called in 2012, the Senior Counsel said as he sought to establish the motivations behind AHTC's decisions that led to a new managing agent being appointed.

The sole firm that bid for the contract, Mr Davinder Singh noted, was the incumbent, FM Solutions and Services (FMSS), owned by staunch supporters of the WP.

Mr Pritam Singh is the third defendant in the ongoing trial of a multimillion-dollar civil lawsuit over alleged improper payments made by the town councillors to FMSS and its service provider. The first two were former WP chief Low Thia Khiang and WP chairman Sylvia Lim.

Mr Davinder Singh put to Mr Pritam Singh: "A responsible town councillor would apply his mind to the implications of waiving his tender on future prospects of parties in industry being interested in making a bid."

The WP chief replied: "I disagree because a responsible town councillor needs to understand what is the difference between his town council, PAP (People's Action Party) town councils and the reality of the politicised town council space in Singapore.

"After the responsible town councillor goes through that process, he will understand why AHTC, as the first opposition GRC, had to take the decisions it did, particularly after Mr Lee Kuan Yew himself warned that Aljunied residents had five years to repent," he added.

He was referring to a warning Singapore's founding prime minister gave to Aljunied voters a week before Voting Day on May 7, 2011, that they would "live and repent" if the PAP were defeated in the GRC.

Mr Davinder Singh said if Mr Pritam Singh honestly believed it was in AHTC's interest to waive the tender in 2011, the responsible thing to do would have been to "lock in" FMSS to the rates of the former agent, CPG Facilities Management for two years, rather than just one.

This would have helped AHTC avoid the rise in managing agent rates in 2012, when FMSS was the sole bidder in the open tender.

Disagreeing, Mr Pritam Singh said it was a better idea to give FMSS a one-year contract and then call for a tender, so that the town council could gather appropriate rates from other players.

"You cannot have it both ways," said Mr Davinder Singh, "and expect that the market would open up and embrace an opposition-run town council a year later after saying the companies would not touch AHTC."

Mr Davinder Singh also asked why the WP MPs waited until a town council meeting to inform the other councillors about the appointment of FMSS, instead of informing them earlier, like via a "two-minute" e-mail.

The WP chief said a meeting would be a better platform for the councillors to scrutinise the decision.

Mr Davinder Singh pointed out the meeting was postponed from July 27 to Aug 4, further delaying the councillors being informed and residents being told of FMSS' appointment.

Mr Pritam Singh replied: "I don't think there was any nefarious plot on that."

Mr Davinder Singh also sought several times to get Mr Pritam Singh to remember certain dates, including when he learnt Ms Lim and Mr Low were involved in talks on forming a managing agency.

The WP chief said he could not remember, as the events took place seven years ago.

Mr Davinder Singh referred him to his affidavit, in which he mentioned several meetings, one as early as in June 2012.

"I suggest to you that having remembered it so clearly in your affidavit...which you filed last month, on the stand you create a completely different impression," he added.

Mr Pritam Singh said he had nothing to hide.

FOR MORE, READ THE STRAITS TIMES TODAY